ILLINOIS DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION PAGE: 1 04/10/12 09:47:55 U N I T P R I C E T A B U L A T I O N O F B I D S LETTING DATE: 01/20/2012 LETTING TYPE: SCHEDULED CONTRACT NUMBER: 91450 LETTING ITEM NUMBER: 053 RESPONSIBLE DISTRICT: 05 BIDS LOCKED: Y SECTION: 09-18131-00-BR COUNTY: MCLEAN ESTIMATE: STATE JOB NUMBER: C-95-309-11 MUNICIPALITY: PROJECT NUMBER: BROS-0113/033/000 -------------------------- SUMMARY OF CONTRACTOR BIDS -------------------------- "AS READ" SUMMATION SUMMATION OF NBR BIDR CONTR COMB ITEM CONTR BIDDER OF BIDDER CALCULATED LOW BIDR CALC BLANK NBR BIDDER NAME GROUP COMB GRP NBR GROUP TOTAL PRICE EXTENSIONS EXTENSIONS BID EXTENSION DIFF BIDS 0335 Otto Baum Company, Inc. NO ALT 298,214.35 298,214.35 298,214.35 1690 H. J. Eppel & Co. NO ALT 280,984.15 * 280,984.15 280,984.15 * 4545 O'Neil Bros., a Division of MACC of ILL., Inc. NO ALT 387,879.46 387,879.46 387,879.46 5040 Riber Construction, Inc. NO ALT 288,654.50 288,654.50 288,654.50 5672 Stark Excavating, Inc. NO ALT 301,939.85 301,939.85 301,939.85 5991 Tobey's Construction & Cartage, Inc. NO ALT 323,994.46 323,994.46 323,994.46 **** TOTAL GROUP NO ALT PAY ITEMS FOR THIS CONTRACT = 26 ---------------------- DETAIL CONTRACTOR BIDS ---------------------- ITEM NBR ITEM DESCRIPTION UNIT OF UNIT BIDDER CALCULATED BIDR CALC BIDR NBR BIDDER NAME QUANTITY MEASURE PRICE EXTENSION EXTENSION EXTENSION DIFF LR631020 TRAF BAR TERM T1 4.000 EACH 1690 H. J. Eppel & Co. 1,492.0000 5,968.00 5,968.00 4545 O'Neil Bros., a Division of MACC of ILL., Inc. 1,435.0000 5,740.00 5,740.00 0335 Otto Baum Company, Inc. 1,625.0000 6,500.00 6,500.00 5040 Riber Construction, Inc. 1,435.0000 5,740.00 5,740.00 5672 Stark Excavating, Inc. 1,435.0000 5,740.00 5,740.00 5991 Tobey's Construction & Cartage, Inc. 1,325.0000 5,300.00 5,300.00 X2501000 SEEDING CL 2 SPL .300 ACRE 1690 H. J. Eppel & Co. 9,612.0000 2,883.60 2,883.60 4545 O'Neil Bros., a Division of MACC of ILL., Inc. 11,786.8400 3,536.05 3,536.05 0335 Otto Baum Company, Inc. 9,700.0000 2,910.00 2,910.00 5040 Riber Construction, Inc. 11,700.0000 3,510.00 3,510.00 5672 Stark Excavating, Inc. 13,080.0000 3,924.00 3,924.00 5991 Tobey's Construction & Cartage, Inc. 8,589.8700 2,576.96 2,576.96 X2810208 STONE RIPRAP CL A4 SP 200.000 TON 1690 H. J. Eppel & Co. 39.0000 7,800.00 7,800.00 4545 O'Neil Bros., a Division of MACC of ILL., Inc. 65.0000 13,000.00 13,000.00 0335 Otto Baum Company, Inc. 60.0000 12,000.00 12,000.00 5040 Riber Construction, Inc. 55.0000 11,000.00 11,000.00 5672 Stark Excavating, Inc. 64.0000 12,800.00 12,800.00 5991 Tobey's Construction & Cartage, Inc. 64.0000 12,800.00 12,800.00 Z0046304 P UNDR FOR STRUCT 4 106.000 FOOT 1690 H. J. Eppel & Co. 6.8000 720.80 720.80 4545 O'Neil Bros., a Division of MACC of ILL., Inc. 37.0000 3,922.00 3,922.00 0335 Otto Baum Company, Inc. 18.0000 1,908.00 1,908.00 5040 Riber Construction, Inc. 17.0000 1,802.00 1,802.00 5672 Stark Excavating, Inc. 23.0000 2,438.00 2,438.00 5991 Tobey's Construction & Cartage, Inc. 24.0000 2,544.00 2,544.00 20200100 EARTH EXCAVATION 85.000 CU YD 1690 H. J. Eppel & Co. 25.0000 2,125.00 2,125.00 4545 O'Neil Bros., a Division of MACC of ILL., Inc. 30.0000 2,550.00 2,550.00 0335 Otto Baum Company, Inc. 22.0000 1,870.00 1,870.00 5040 Riber Construction, Inc. 19.0000 1,615.00 1,615.00 5672 Stark Excavating, Inc. 46.0000 3,910.00 3,910.00 5991 Tobey's Construction & Cartage, Inc. 17.0000 1,445.00 1,445.00 20300100 CHANNEL EXCAVATION 170.000 CU YD 1690 H. J. Eppel & Co. 26.0000 4,420.00 4,420.00 4545 O'Neil Bros., a Division of MACC of ILL., Inc. 23.0000 3,910.00 3,910.00 0335 Otto Baum Company, Inc. 17.0000 2,890.00 2,890.00 5040 Riber Construction, Inc. 21.0000 3,570.00 3,570.00 5672 Stark Excavating, Inc. 14.0000 2,380.00 2,380.00 5991 Tobey's Construction & Cartage, Inc. 17.0000 2,890.00 2,890.00 20400800 FURNISHED EXCAVATION 220.000 CU YD 1690 H. J. Eppel & Co. 34.0000 7,480.00 7,480.00 4545 O'Neil Bros., a Division of MACC of ILL., Inc. 33.0000 7,260.00 7,260.00 0335 Otto Baum Company, Inc. 35.0000 7,700.00 7,700.00 5040 Riber Construction, Inc. 23.0000 5,060.00 5,060.00 5672 Stark Excavating, Inc. 27.0000 5,940.00 5,940.00 5991 Tobey's Construction & Cartage, Inc. 17.0000 3,740.00 3,740.00 20700110 POROUS GRAN EMBANK 90.000 TON 1690 H. J. Eppel & Co. 34.0000 3,060.00 3,060.00 4545 O'Neil Bros., a Division of MACC of ILL., Inc. 51.0000 4,590.00 4,590.00 0335 Otto Baum Company, Inc. 25.0000 2,250.00 2,250.00 5040 Riber Construction, Inc. 35.0000 3,150.00 3,150.00 5672 Stark Excavating, Inc. 42.0000 3,780.00 3,780.00 5991 Tobey's Construction & Cartage, Inc. 33.0000 2,970.00 2,970.00 28000400 PERIMETER EROS BAR 250.000 FOOT 1690 H. J. Eppel & Co. 3.4000 850.00 850.00 4545 O'Neil Bros., a Division of MACC of ILL., Inc. 4.0000 1,000.00 1,000.00 0335 Otto Baum Company, Inc. 2.8500 712.50 712.50 5040 Riber Construction, Inc. 6.0000 1,500.00 1,500.00 5672 Stark Excavating, Inc. 4.5000 1,125.00 1,125.00 5991 Tobey's Construction & Cartage, Inc. 6.0000 1,500.00 1,500.00 40200800 AGG SURF CSE B 634.000 TON 1690 H. J. Eppel & Co. 26.0000 16,484.00 16,484.00 4545 O'Neil Bros., a Division of MACC of ILL., Inc. 32.0000 20,288.00 20,288.00 0335 Otto Baum Company, Inc. 25.0000 15,850.00 15,850.00 5040 Riber Construction, Inc. 19.5000 12,363.00 12,363.00 5672 Stark Excavating, Inc. 26.5000 16,801.00 16,801.00 5991 Tobey's Construction & Cartage, Inc. 23.0000 14,582.00 14,582.00 50100100 REM EXIST STRUCT 1.000 EACH 1690 H. J. Eppel & Co. 10,000.0000 10,000.00 10,000.00 4545 O'Neil Bros., a Division of MACC of ILL., Inc. 11,000.0000 11,000.00 11,000.00 0335 Otto Baum Company, Inc. 15,000.0000 15,000.00 15,000.00 5040 Riber Construction, Inc. 10,300.0000 10,300.00 10,300.00 5672 Stark Excavating, Inc. 15,600.0000 15,600.00 15,600.00 5991 Tobey's Construction & Cartage, Inc. 16,000.0000 16,000.00 16,000.00 50300225 CONC STRUCT 32.700 CU YD 1690 H. J. Eppel & Co. 830.0000 27,141.00 27,141.00 4545 O'Neil Bros., a Division of MACC of ILL., Inc. 1,122.0000 36,689.40 36,689.40 0335 Otto Baum Company, Inc. 1,000.0000 32,700.00 32,700.00 5040 Riber Construction, Inc. 850.0000 27,795.00 27,795.00 5672 Stark Excavating, Inc. 955.0000 31,228.50 31,228.50 5991 Tobey's Construction & Cartage, Inc. 1,175.0000 38,422.50 38,422.50 50300255 CONC SUP-STR 67.100 CU YD 1690 H. J. Eppel & Co. 1,075.0000 72,132.50 72,132.50 4545 O'Neil Bros., a Division of MACC of ILL., Inc. 1,586.0000 106,420.60 106,420.60 0335 Otto Baum Company, Inc. 950.0000 63,745.00 63,745.00 5040 Riber Construction, Inc. 1,240.0000 83,204.00 83,204.00 5672 Stark Excavating, Inc. 955.0000 64,080.50 64,080.50 5991 Tobey's Construction & Cartage, Inc. 1,275.0000 85,552.50 85,552.50 50300280 CONCRETE ENCASEMENT 10.200 CU YD 1690 H. J. Eppel & Co. 1,400.0000 14,280.00 14,280.00 4545 O'Neil Bros., a Division of MACC of ILL., Inc. 990.0000 10,098.00 10,098.00 0335 Otto Baum Company, Inc. 1,800.0000 18,360.00 18,360.00 5040 Riber Construction, Inc. 1,550.0000 15,810.00 15,810.00 5672 Stark Excavating, Inc. 1,600.0000 16,320.00 16,320.00 5991 Tobey's Construction & Cartage, Inc. 1,000.0000 10,200.00 10,200.00 50800205 REINF BARS, EPOXY CTD 22,840.000 POUND 1690 H. J. Eppel & Co. 1.3000 29,692.00 29,692.00 4545 O'Neil Bros., a Division of MACC of ILL., Inc. 2.0000 45,680.00 45,680.00 0335 Otto Baum Company, Inc. 1.5000 34,260.00 34,260.00 5040 Riber Construction, Inc. 1.3000 29,692.00 29,692.00 5672 Stark Excavating, Inc. 1.4500 33,118.00 33,118.00 5991 Tobey's Construction & Cartage, Inc. 1.4500 33,118.00 33,118.00 50900205 STEEL RAILING TY S1 116.000 FOOT 1690 H. J. Eppel & Co. 100.0000 11,600.00 11,600.00 4545 O'Neil Bros., a Division of MACC of ILL., Inc. 96.5500 11,199.80 11,199.80 0335 Otto Baum Company, Inc. 108.0000 12,528.00 12,528.00 5040 Riber Construction, Inc. 96.5500 11,199.80 11,199.80 5672 Stark Excavating, Inc. 96.5000 11,194.00 11,194.00 5991 Tobey's Construction & Cartage, Inc. 93.5000 10,846.00 10,846.00 51201400 FUR STL PILE HP10X42 685.000 FOOT 1690 H. J. Eppel & Co. 55.0000 37,675.00 37,675.00 4545 O'Neil Bros., a Division of MACC of ILL., Inc. 49.0000 33,565.00 33,565.00 0335 Otto Baum Company, Inc. 50.0000 34,250.00 34,250.00 5040 Riber Construction, Inc. 40.0000 27,400.00 27,400.00 5672 Stark Excavating, Inc. 44.0000 30,140.00 30,140.00 5991 Tobey's Construction & Cartage, Inc. 30.0000 20,550.00 20,550.00 51202305 DRIVING PILES 685.000 FOOT 1690 H. J. Eppel & Co. 0.4500 308.25 308.25 4545 O'Neil Bros., a Division of MACC of ILL., Inc. 1.0000 685.00 685.00 0335 Otto Baum Company, Inc. 0.0100 6.85 6.85 5040 Riber Construction, Inc. 0.1000 68.50 68.50 5672 Stark Excavating, Inc. 0.0100 6.85 6.85 5991 Tobey's Construction & Cartage, Inc. 0.1000 68.50 68.50 51203400 TEST PILE ST HP10X42 2.000 EACH 1690 H. J. Eppel & Co. 3,000.0000 6,000.00 6,000.00 4545 O'Neil Bros., a Division of MACC of ILL., Inc. 4,200.0000 8,400.00 8,400.00 0335 Otto Baum Company, Inc. 3,000.0000 6,000.00 6,000.00 5040 Riber Construction, Inc. 6,000.0000 12,000.00 12,000.00 5672 Stark Excavating, Inc. 2,700.0000 5,400.00 5,400.00 5991 Tobey's Construction & Cartage, Inc. 9,680.0000 19,360.00 19,360.00 51500100 NAME PLATES 1.000 EACH 1690 H. J. Eppel & Co. 350.0000 350.00 350.00 4545 O'Neil Bros., a Division of MACC of ILL., Inc. 400.0000 400.00 400.00 0335 Otto Baum Company, Inc. 450.0000 450.00 450.00 5040 Riber Construction, Inc. 400.0000 400.00 400.00 5672 Stark Excavating, Inc. 450.0000 450.00 450.00 5991 Tobey's Construction & Cartage, Inc. 445.0000 445.00 445.00 542D0220 P CUL CL D 1 15 432.000 FOOT 1690 H. J. Eppel & Co. 27.0000 11,664.00 11,664.00 4545 O'Neil Bros., a Division of MACC of ILL., Inc. 22.0000 9,504.00 9,504.00 0335 Otto Baum Company, Inc. 20.0000 8,640.00 8,640.00 5040 Riber Construction, Inc. 21.6000 9,331.20 9,331.20 5672 Stark Excavating, Inc. 30.0000 12,960.00 12,960.00 5991 Tobey's Construction & Cartage, Inc. 26.0000 11,232.00 11,232.00 59100100 GEOCOMPOSITE WALL DR 32.000 SQ YD 1690 H. J. Eppel & Co. 11.0000 352.00 352.00 4545 O'Neil Bros., a Division of MACC of ILL., Inc. 18.0000 576.00 576.00 0335 Otto Baum Company, Inc. 17.0000 544.00 544.00 5040 Riber Construction, Inc. 22.0000 704.00 704.00 5672 Stark Excavating, Inc. 27.0000 864.00 864.00 5991 Tobey's Construction & Cartage, Inc. 37.0000 1,184.00 1,184.00 63100075 TRAF BAR TERM T5A 4.000 EACH 1690 H. J. Eppel & Co. 1,000.0000 4,000.00 4,000.00 4545 O'Neil Bros., a Division of MACC of ILL., Inc. 975.0000 3,900.00 3,900.00 0335 Otto Baum Company, Inc. 1,000.0000 4,000.00 4,000.00 5040 Riber Construction, Inc. 975.0000 3,900.00 3,900.00 5672 Stark Excavating, Inc. 975.0000 3,900.00 3,900.00 5991 Tobey's Construction & Cartage, Inc. 800.0000 3,200.00 3,200.00 67100100 MOBILIZATION 1.000 L SUM 1690 H. J. Eppel & Co. 3,000.0000 3,000.00 3,000.00 4545 O'Neil Bros., a Division of MACC of ILL., Inc. 41,325.6100 41,325.61 41,325.61 0335 Otto Baum Company, Inc. 9,000.0000 9,000.00 9,000.00 5040 Riber Construction, Inc. 4,000.0000 4,000.00 4,000.00 5672 Stark Excavating, Inc. 15,000.0000 15,000.00 15,000.00 5991 Tobey's Construction & Cartage, Inc. 19,500.0000 19,500.00 19,500.00 70101830 TRAF CONT-PROT BLR 21 1.000 L SUM 1690 H. J. Eppel & Co. 850.0000 850.00 850.00 4545 O'Neil Bros., a Division of MACC of ILL., Inc. 2,500.0000 2,500.00 2,500.00 0335 Otto Baum Company, Inc. 4,000.0000 4,000.00 4,000.00 5040 Riber Construction, Inc. 3,400.0000 3,400.00 3,400.00 5672 Stark Excavating, Inc. 2,700.0000 2,700.00 2,700.00 5991 Tobey's Construction & Cartage, Inc. 3,848.0000 3,848.00 3,848.00 78201000 TERMINAL MARKER - DA 4.000 EACH 1690 H. J. Eppel & Co. 37.0000 148.00 148.00 4545 O'Neil Bros., a Division of MACC of ILL., Inc. 35.0000 140.00 140.00 0335 Otto Baum Company, Inc. 35.0000 140.00 140.00 5040 Riber Construction, Inc. 35.0000 140.00 140.00 5672 Stark Excavating, Inc. 35.0000 140.00 140.00 5991 Tobey's Construction & Cartage, Inc. 30.0000 120.00 120.00