ILLINOIS DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION PAGE: 1 03/05/10 16:23:57 U N I T P R I C E T A B U L A T I O N O F B I D S LETTING DATE: 01/15/2010 LETTING TYPE: SCHEDULED CONTRACT NUMBER: 97412 LETTING ITEM NUMBER: 256 RESPONSIBLE DISTRICT: 08 BIDS LOCKED: Y SECTION: 09-00085-00-RS COUNTY: WASHINGTON ESTIMATE: STATE JOB NUMBER: C-98-302-10 MUNICIPALITY: PROJECT NUMBER: ARA-RS-0788/112/000 -------------------------- SUMMARY OF CONTRACTOR BIDS -------------------------- "AS READ" SUMMATION SUMMATION OF NBR BIDR CONTR COMB ITEM CONTR BIDDER OF BIDDER CALCULATED LOW BIDR CALC BLANK NBR BIDDER NAME GROUP COMB GRP NBR GROUP TOTAL PRICE EXTENSIONS EXTENSIONS BID EXTENSION DIFF BIDS 1034 Christ Bros. Asphalt, Inc. NO ALT 967,633.92 967,633.92 967,633.92 2688 Howell Asphalt Company & Howell Paving, Inc. NO ALT 835,056.68 835,056.68 835,056.68 3157 The Kilian Corporation NO ALT 827,250.45 * 827,250.45 827,250.45 * **** TOTAL GROUP NO ALT PAY ITEMS FOR THIS CONTRACT = 25 ---------------------- DETAIL CONTRACTOR BIDS ---------------------- ITEM NBR ITEM DESCRIPTION UNIT OF UNIT BIDDER CALCULATED BIDR CALC BIDR NBR BIDDER NAME QUANTITY MEASURE PRICE EXTENSION EXTENSION EXTENSION DIFF 20200410 EARTH EXCAVATION SPL 1,393.000 CU YD 1034 Christ Bros. Asphalt, Inc. 37.0000 51,541.00 51,541.00 2688 Howell Asphalt Company & Howell Paving, Inc. 26.8300 37,374.19 37,374.19 3157 The Kilian Corporation 13.0000 18,109.00 18,109.00 20400800 FURNISHED EXCAVATION 62.000 CU YD 1034 Christ Bros. Asphalt, Inc. 99.4800 6,167.76 6,167.76 2688 Howell Asphalt Company & Howell Paving, Inc. 53.4600 3,314.52 3,314.52 3157 The Kilian Corporation 75.0000 4,650.00 4,650.00 25001000 SEEDING CL 2 SPL .250 ACRE 1034 Christ Bros. Asphalt, Inc. 10,587.2000 2,646.80 2,646.80 2688 Howell Asphalt Company & Howell Paving, Inc. 10,587.2000 2,646.80 2,646.80 3157 The Kilian Corporation 12,000.0000 3,000.00 3,000.00 28000305 TEMP DITCH CHECKS 16.000 FOOT 1034 Christ Bros. Asphalt, Inc. 150.0000 2,400.00 2,400.00 2688 Howell Asphalt Company & Howell Paving, Inc. 11.3200 181.12 181.12 3157 The Kilian Corporation 125.0000 2,000.00 2,000.00 28000720 MULCH METHOD 2 .250 ACRE 1034 Christ Bros. Asphalt, Inc. 9,126.0000 2,281.50 2,281.50 2688 Howell Asphalt Company & Howell Paving, Inc. 9,126.0000 2,281.50 2,281.50 3157 The Kilian Corporation 4,000.0000 1,000.00 1,000.00 40200800 AGG SURF CSE B 87.000 TON 1034 Christ Bros. Asphalt, Inc. 58.9400 5,127.78 5,127.78 2688 Howell Asphalt Company & Howell Paving, Inc. 45.2000 3,932.40 3,932.40 3157 The Kilian Corporation 38.0000 3,306.00 3,306.00 40600100 BIT MATLS PR CT 4,232.000 GALLON 1034 Christ Bros. Asphalt, Inc. 0.0100 42.32 42.32 2688 Howell Asphalt Company & Howell Paving, Inc. 1.9900 8,421.68 8,421.68 3157 The Kilian Corporation 0.0100 42.32 42.32 40600300 AGG PR CT 85.000 TON 1034 Christ Bros. Asphalt, Inc. 0.0100 0.85 0.85 2688 Howell Asphalt Company & Howell Paving, Inc. 0.0000 0.00 0.00 3157 The Kilian Corporation 0.0100 0.85 0.85 40600625 LEV BIND MM N50 2,340.000 TON 1034 Christ Bros. Asphalt, Inc. 77.0000 180,180.00 180,180.00 2688 Howell Asphalt Company & Howell Paving, Inc. 67.0000 156,780.00 156,780.00 3157 The Kilian Corporation 66.0000 154,440.00 154,440.00 40600895 CONSTRUC TEST STRIP 1.000 EACH 1034 Christ Bros. Asphalt, Inc. 1,250.0000 1,250.00 1,250.00 2688 Howell Asphalt Company & Howell Paving, Inc. 2,509.4100 2,509.41 2,509.41 3157 The Kilian Corporation 500.0000 500.00 500.00 40600982 HMA SURF REM BUTT JT 174.000 SQ YD 1034 Christ Bros. Asphalt, Inc. 16.5800 2,884.92 2,884.92 2688 Howell Asphalt Company & Howell Paving, Inc. 16.6100 2,890.14 2,890.14 3157 The Kilian Corporation 10.0000 1,740.00 1,740.00 40600990 TEMPORARY RAMP 29.000 SQ YD 1034 Christ Bros. Asphalt, Inc. 25.0000 725.00 725.00 2688 Howell Asphalt Company & Howell Paving, Inc. 0.0000 0.00 0.00 3157 The Kilian Corporation 0.0100 0.29 0.29 40603310 HMA SC "C" N50 3,875.000 TON 1034 Christ Bros. Asphalt, Inc. 78.0000 302,250.00 302,250.00 2688 Howell Asphalt Company & Howell Paving, Inc. 66.0000 255,750.00 255,750.00 3157 The Kilian Corporation 66.0000 255,750.00 255,750.00 40800050 INCIDENTAL HMA SURF 132.000 TON 1034 Christ Bros. Asphalt, Inc. 187.3100 24,724.92 24,724.92 2688 Howell Asphalt Company & Howell Paving, Inc. 172.4000 22,756.80 22,756.80 3157 The Kilian Corporation 150.0000 19,800.00 19,800.00 44201741 CL D PATCH T2 8 696.000 SQ YD 1034 Christ Bros. Asphalt, Inc. 86.4000 60,134.40 60,134.40 2688 Howell Asphalt Company & Howell Paving, Inc. 91.4600 63,656.16 63,656.16 3157 The Kilian Corporation 80.0000 55,680.00 55,680.00 44300300 AREA REF CR CON TR A 2,320.000 SQ YD 1034 Christ Bros. Asphalt, Inc. 1.6700 3,874.40 3,874.40 2688 Howell Asphalt Company & Howell Paving, Inc. 1.6700 3,874.40 3,874.40 3157 The Kilian Corporation 1.4500 3,364.00 3,364.00 44300900 STRIP REF CR CON TR A 18,975.000 FOOT 1034 Christ Bros. Asphalt, Inc. 0.6700 12,713.25 12,713.25 2688 Howell Asphalt Company & Howell Paving, Inc. 0.6700 12,713.25 12,713.25 3157 The Kilian Corporation 0.4400 8,349.00 8,349.00 48102100 AGG WEDGE SHLD TYPE B 838.000 TON 1034 Christ Bros. Asphalt, Inc. 33.8100 28,332.78 28,332.78 2688 Howell Asphalt Company & Howell Paving, Inc. 26.9200 22,558.96 22,558.96 3157 The Kilian Corporation 29.0000 24,302.00 24,302.00 48203021 HMA SHOULDERS 6 8,354.000 SQ YD 1034 Christ Bros. Asphalt, Inc. 27.5000 229,735.00 229,735.00 2688 Howell Asphalt Company & Howell Paving, Inc. 24.0000 200,496.00 200,496.00 3157 The Kilian Corporation 23.3500 195,065.90 195,065.90 67100100 MOBILIZATION 1.000 L SUM 1034 Christ Bros. Asphalt, Inc. 25,750.0000 25,750.00 25,750.00 2688 Howell Asphalt Company & Howell Paving, Inc. 7,500.0000 7,500.00 7,500.00 3157 The Kilian Corporation 46,465.0000 46,465.00 46,465.00 70103700 TRAF CONT COMPL 1.000 L SUM 1034 Christ Bros. Asphalt, Inc. 8,500.0000 8,500.00 8,500.00 2688 Howell Asphalt Company & Howell Paving, Inc. 6,241.6000 6,241.60 6,241.60 3157 The Kilian Corporation 7,500.0000 7,500.00 7,500.00 70300100 SHORT-TERM PAVT MKING 5,693.000 FOOT 1034 Christ Bros. Asphalt, Inc. 0.0100 56.93 56.93 2688 Howell Asphalt Company & Howell Paving, Inc. 0.4400 2,504.92 2,504.92 3157 The Kilian Corporation 0.0100 56.93 56.93 70300220 TEMP PVT MK LINE 4 44,539.000 FOOT 1034 Christ Bros. Asphalt, Inc. 0.0000 0.00 0.00 2688 Howell Asphalt Company & Howell Paving, Inc. 0.0000 0.00 0.00 3157 The Kilian Corporation 0.0000 0.00 0.00 70301000 WORK ZONE PAVT MK REM 633.000 SQ FT 1034 Christ Bros. Asphalt, Inc. 1.8500 1,171.05 1,171.05 2688 Howell Asphalt Company & Howell Paving, Inc. 3.1200 1,974.96 1,974.96 3157 The Kilian Corporation 4.0000 2,532.00 2,532.00 78000200 THPL PVT MK LINE 4 44,539.000 FOOT 1034 Christ Bros. Asphalt, Inc. 0.3400 15,143.26 15,143.26 2688 Howell Asphalt Company & Howell Paving, Inc. 0.3300 14,697.87 14,697.87 3157 The Kilian Corporation 0.4400 19,597.16 19,597.16